Hey that was a shot at me wasn't it?
I have no intention what so ever to disclose any kind of personal information to strangers in public media, sorry, it seems like you'll just have to belive me.
Wanderer, the main problem with your arguments is, you don't give parameters for your "facts" and worse you treat everyone else who dissagree with you like they are small kids who don't know nothing.
I'm not saying that I disagree with you OTOH i'm not saying that I agree either, it's all depends on so many factors that we can't calculate the outcome.
For every space combat scenario that you propose you need to lay down several parameters first, for exemple:
1. Is in newtonian?
2. What is your main propulsion method?
3. What the general tech levels in: computer science, sensors, physics, lasers\rail guns\missiles etc etc...
4. What is the space navy mission?
5. Do you fight humanes or aliens?
6. Economic level?
7. Level of space industry?
8. Etc etc etc....
Once you have the basic parameters laid down you can start proposing your ideas and state them as facts.
If you want to get some basic knowledge on spaceflight, I really recommend reading Intreduction to spaceflight by francis Hale, excellent reading.