You, dear Sir, have no taste in TV. Voyager was kick-ass. You're just unhappy because it places a woman in charge, or because it actually looks like a pretty ship.
You almost make it sound unrealistic, and we all know just how many space-ships with warp engines that we can compare it to
Imho, DS9 was the weakest of all the shows - it was so...un-Star Trekkie. Still, we can't change history..sadly. Lmao
Where to begin?
While I have nothing against any of the 5 "canon" Star Trek shows, I consider DS9 to be the best of them, followed closely by TNG. I grew up during the "TNG-era", so that was also the first show I watched. Was about 4 years old when it first premiered here in Sweden.
Voyager had it's share of moments, but the one thing that I will never forgive Rick Berman for, is making the Borg the "weak-ass" bad guys they were shown as in Voyager. Here we have a ship which is little more than a "deep space explorer", armed with a limited amount of phasers, only 38 photon torpedoes (pilot episode) and with no other ships around as backup. Traveling home through the Delta Quadrant, which had long been estabilished as the home of TNG's arch-nemesis, the Borg. And when the Borg finally do make an appearance in the show, what did the producers do?
Introduce a "bombshell" in the form of Jeri Ryan/Seven of Nine, primarily to attract the younger teenage boys and to boost the then failing ratings of the show. Further encounters with the Borg, showed them to be "gullable" and easily defeated. Janeway's first encounter with them, resulted in a temporary alliance with the Borg to defeat Species 8472 (which the Borg originally attacked). The alliance was ofcourse broken, and if you follow through to the series finale, "Admiral" Janeway eventually developed technologies during her travel home to Earth, to defeat the Borg.
Now unless this technology was more advanced than that of Species 8472, I really don't see that happening. Species 8472 was the only species the Borg have never been able to assimilate. We've seen dozens of Borg cubes get wiped out near instantly by 8472's ships.
As I said, Voyager had it's moments, but all of which culminated in the series finale with the "uber" armor technology, and the 1-shot torpedo technology, pretty much negating any "effort" on the part of the Voyager crew. I would've much preferred them to have been destroyed in the finale, never reaching home... or to be on a "continuous" search for home, and not show us the resolution of their travels. Would've left an opening for making a Voyager-movie in that case.
If it were up to me, they should have done a DS9 movie long before the JJ Abrams Trek that was released earlier this year. Don't get me wrong, I enjoyed the movie... but it was of a decidedly different style to past Trek incarnations.