In my opinion, that Advent Titan that sareth wasted so much of his and our time bitching about, is the best looking one I've seen.
While I do agree that some of the Advent ships are rather poor in design (Revelation, Progenitor, Destra, Talion, Missionary), some are in the middleground (Disciple, Illuminator, Purge, Aeria), most of the rest are outstanding, in my humble opinion (Radiance, Halcyon, Rapture, Transcencia, Beam Platform, Iconus, Domina).
Also in my opinion, its that second Advent Titan you have to worry about, and that oversized fighter of the Vasari.
There are many who will disagree with me. I know. Among them is sareth. What is my point?
Ask yourself: Would these models have been put in the game without StarClad thoroughly looking over them first? Obvious answer: No. LucasArts or EA: Yes, probably, but StarClad isn't like that. They actually check their work. And although they swung and missed with a few things, they're not game-breaking, and they usually come right back and fix them. As for misses on designs, well, again, they're not game-breaking, and I don't see many rant threads about how poorly designed ship models are, so they must've done something right.
i think, most people do not care that much, thats why there are no rant threads. In the end, its a matter of personal taste, some people with some kind of design background may be more qualified to judge, bur ultimately, its just their opinion, nothing more. Thats why its almost pointless to talk about it, no consensus is going to be reached about this...ever