Edit: As I say in my post after this I am sorry for being so hot headed. Please read the post after this, I have been a jerk with this post. Sorry. Sincerely, GrandAdmiralSova117.
This is like talking to a wall. I obviously have a mental defect to be continuing.
Capital ships in Star Trek move faster than fighters in Halo, no speed advantage there. Star Trek doesn't use fighters too often because when you can hit a dime from the other side of a planet, you can't really do much with them. Mobility over durability only works when you can avoid being shot. They can't.
Covenant fighters would be so many explosions as they winked out of existence before ever getting into firing range. The Covenant capital ships wouldn't be in a much better position. They'd be going boom before getting into firing range too. Since they're so godawfully slow, they'd never get into firing range either.
They aren't scaled anywhere near each other.
Start a Stargate versus Halo thread. Those two are pretty similar. A godlike, and no longer present species of old with weapons that can exterminate everything in the galaxy, a technologically advanced bunch of religious wackjobs playing at an interstellar empire while severely under utilizing their technological advantage, and a backwards bunch of primates running around with solid propellant projectile weapons. You'll still be a blind Halo fan with no grasp of reality, but at least you'd sound rational.
Edit: Full impulse, which is no warp field, is over 1/4c.
Edit again: G's don't exist for pilots in Star Trek. They use a magical device called an inertial dampener to get rid of them! A common sense prerequisit for anything resembling interstellar warfare.
GOD DAMN COMPUTER! Can't get it to stay on until now without massive lag. And your not talking to a wall! I AM! I'M THE ONE WITH THE MENTAL DEFECT!
Back this stuff up like I have! So me a ST ship hitting a dime from ten thousand kilometers away! The line of text that was here has been replaced by the following transmission from GAS117: I have been a jerk sorry, really really sorry-GrandAdmiralSova117. Give me proof that I can see on screen in an ST show with them hitting a small target moving very fast thousands of kilometers away; and not just say that they can! I have given you data, now give me data from ST that is true!
ANS WHAT PART OF MILLIONS OF KILOMETERS RANGE IN NORMAL SPACE AND 150,000 KILOMETERS PER-SECOND did you not get? As far as I know ST ships from the Federation have never engage at those ranges in normal space.
And what makes you so sure that those fighters will be lighting up the sky like fire works? THERE WOULD HUNDREDS IF NOT THOUSANDS CAMING AT YOU DODGING PHASERS AND TORPEDOS, SURE YOU WILL SHOOT DOWN A FEW HUNDRED BUT YOU WILL HAVE ALL READY BEEN GUTTED BY AN ENERGY PROJECTOR BLAST OR A WAVE OF DOZENS OF PLASMA TORPEDOS COMING FROM MILLIONS OF KILOMETERS AWAY AT 150,000 KILOMETERS PER-SECOND THAT WILL MELT RIGHT THROUGH YOUR SHIELDS THEN THROUGH THE DECKS AND BLOW UP THAT DAMN AM REACTOR!
I have back up everything here, I gave you info on my sources, NOVA bomb is The Ghosts of Onyx. Now back up the things you post with things that can be seen on screen happening in an ST show.
And I don't much about SG-1 or any other SG show besides the 1994 movie. And I don't know much about 40K either, I was thinking of getting the Dawn of War game before my XP went bonkers.
And sorry about getting Impulse and the G's thing wrong . You do know that the Covenant have the same thing and have a Forerunner Dreadnought, right? And how do you know how fast their ships are? And your forgeting they can be millions of kilometers away and be no more then a kilometer away by going thought Slipspace. I know that ST has it's onw version, but you can't get into Halo Slipspace with one of the drives. They can just enter the stream and appear all around you will your shooting at something else.
I have been civil and but your to thick head to take in any of my data and compare it to Federation ships and weapons for these fight, you just have to go thinking that ST is an "invincible juggernaut."
I wanted to keep this civil with no one calling any else names and insulting them, but if you will not take into account any of the data I have posted and give me your sources so I can see then find me some one who will be fair. Now I'm just really anger right now because of the computer, so I don't mean to be rude but I have other things to do.
This has been a very annoyed UNSC transmission.(Because of the computer)