why???? is a lot more easy 2000*1.15 = 2300 with flag 2300/1.15 = 2000 without flag.
No, is not 1739 this is the point where all ur theory falls, player X or Y NEVER EVER are going to have 1739, is easy to see, X or Y just win or go back to his base NEVER go down NEVER u have a 32% of difference.
What kind of calculation takes u to 1739? u never will do down to less than ur base EVER, all your theory is bisaed and bad constructed from the base.
U have one player with 2300 and anotherone with 2000 not more nor less its so easy to understand.
1. We're not even including stuff like going back to your base. When I say base hp it means your hp before any modifiers. If you have 2300 hp with the hp flag, then your base hp is 2000, because that's what your hp is without the flag.
2. I explained just two posts ago where I got every single number and why. If you have 2000 hp including a 15% bonus, then to take away that bonus you divide by 1.15. It's the inverse operation of multiplying by 1.15 which gives the bonus. 1739 base hp. 1739 * 1.15 = 2000 hp with the hp flag capped. Losing the flag means 2000/1.15 = 1739 hp. Back where we started.
3. Calculations and numbers cannot be biased. It is pysically impossible. They might be incorrect, in which case you must point out the error, specifically. Logic might be flawed, but again, it's useless if you don't actually say what is wrong.
4. I can't choose for something to be easy to understand or not, I can only try and explain it the best I can, which is hard if you have trouble with 2000/1.15.
5. I cannot choose whatever numbers I feel like in order to get the result I want. The result is not controlled by me. I can't "cook the books". All I can do is choose numbers that make it easily visible what's going on.
This example I'm trying to use, player x has 2000 hp without the flag and player y has 1739 hp without the flag.
y: 1739 hp -> 2000 when he gets the 15% flag bonus
x: 2000 hp -> 2300 when he gets the 15% flag bonus
It's y against x. The point of choosing these hp amounts for each player is that when y has the flag, he is the same strength as x. This is important because if they both had 2000 hp without the flag, then it's "Well, when y had the flag y won, and when x took the flag x won". Instead, if y has the same hp as x when y has the flag, then it's "Well, when y had the flag it was exactly even, and when x took the flag x won". So all we do is look at the amount x won by and that tells us exactly how much benefit the hp flag gave to x. When you do this, you find that x wins by 32%. Since the only thing that changed was the flag going from y's control to x's control, it must mean that action gave x the 32% benefit.
Everything is below. Everything. Read it slowly and follow. You could pretty much generalise it directly into an informal mathematical proof. To reiterate:
player y: 1739 hp -> 2000 when he gets the 15% flag bonus
player x: 2000 hp -> 2300 when he gets the 15% flag bonus
x has 2000 base, y has 1739 base.
y started with the flag, thus increasing him to 2000 hp. So we have a situation where y has the flag and they both have the same hp. You could try this in-game even.
The thing to note is, y has the flag and they both have 2000 hp and so are equally powerful. The idea is then if they start equally, if x caps the hp flag from y, then it will show us how much benefit the hp flag gave x for capping it.
So x and y are in an equal situation then x takes the flag from y. This changes x's hp to 2300 (2000+15%) and it changes y's hp to 1739 (because he lost his +15%. 1739+15% = 2000). Now it's 2300 vs 1739 and the only thing that happened was x capped the flag from y.
It was equal, then x caps the flag, then we have our result. If we look, 2300 is 32% more than 1739. 32% is the difference from the starting situation and we know the starting situation was an even match between them.