Moved Vahpe and Liadoa to tier 2. Rigler as well. I have never seen those people you mentioned these days so its likely they don't play anymore. I probably need to create a tier 1.5 because there is considerable overlap in tier 2. Added 24601 and Newplayer to tier 3.

Edit: now that i think about it I've seen your name a few times. How would you rank yourself Seleuceia??

Uncrustable, I am puzzled by your hostile response. I was merely trying to do the community a public service by creating a very rough gauge of everyone's abilities. That is why I am open to any and all suggestions. This actually took a very long time, thinking of all the active players and estimating their skill level, something you obviously have no idea about. The entirety of your post is such a mess that I doubt you even read my list. But don't worry, I will refute it point by point:

"Honesfly the entire tier starting jbaum is a joke"- I clearly indicate that order within each tier doesn't matter. 

I'm thinking have a tier 4 is going to be necessary to properly separate people...

Here are some more thoughts that I have...

I have mixed feelings on Pemi at tier 0, he seems more in line with the tier 1 people...I guess it depends on whether you evaluate skill as ability to play as all factions or just your best...

Everyone who is currently on your tier 1 list I think is well placed save Masterial who I don't know at all and thus can't comment on...

Uncrustable should certainly be higher than tier 2 as he is one of the best players there are...I don't have enough games with him and other tier 0 people to see if he is solidly at that level but it wouldn't surprise me if he is...at the very least should be tier 1 for sure...

Fallen might be a tier 1...he is good, can handle the people in tier 2 pretty well and is usually a very high pick in games...I think he has noticeably improved over the last several months (back then I'd say definitely clear tier 2) and so I'd consider moving him up based on the thoughts of other people....

Star might also be tier 1...I don't think he's too rusty anymore, certainly give him time and he'll be back up to that level if he isn't already....

As you suggested, I think it is best to split your tier 2 peoples...Jb, Lia, Hummer, Sugar, Bags, Sin, Brit (even still play?), Multiz, Carpet, Barb, and Vahpe I'd see as being in the new tier 2 while Dirty, Ferdie, and Vet would clearly be in the new tier 3....the other people (Bomb, Rigler, Aeon, Raba, RedTank, Traxsin, Dis, War, and Ana) I'm not sure, could go either way...

The tier 3 (which would be the new tier 4) is probably good for the most part...I would consider moving UNSC up to the new tier 3 (bottom half of current tier 2)....

Kevin and Goodlife are active players (kevin plays as other names)....they'd fit somewhere in the current tier 2 (whether new tier 2 or new tier 3, I can't say)...MJ and Zli also need to be added, probably to the new tier 3 (bottom of current tier 2)....Salty, idk, somewhere between those guys....

As for me, ask Doci, he's been in a ton of games with me and has seen me at my best and my worse...

Addition: thats probably the best sins trolling i have ever seen

Tier 2 player here. Good first draft, although as others have said, needs definite improvement...

@Liadoa- dude stop your trolling, he is solid tier 2...

@Vahpe- haven't seen enough of Vaphe to know his skill level, probably tier 2...

@Rigler- I definitely agree with your points, although I'm not sure how you would know that Seleuceia, considering you don't even play online...

Honestly uncrustable you are definitely tier 1 level, but the few times I saw you play, you quit way too early so its a bit of a risk picking you... I'm not doubting your ability, its just a bad habit you have...

Definitely agree about whip, but disruptor I would say is tier 2.

Your love affair with Seleuceia is getting very tiring... I doubt he can even beat easy AI...

Nice troll attempt...

That is probably whip... 

No he is still rusty.

Doci plays comp stomps???

You are also missing whiplash (different from dirtysanchez), Mulch, and Badeye... I would say all of them are solid tier 1 level...

I dont think RedTank plays anymore...

Hummer you are tier 2, there is no way you are better than sugar or warfleet...

Mostly agree with Sel's tier 2 assessment... Aeonx, War, Anarchy, Dis, Trax, Bomb are in new tier 2 and rigler, rabad, and redtank are in tier 3...

UNSC is def not tier 3... he is probably in the new tier 4...

I am 99% certain strike45 is somebody's smurf, so you might want to update his description...

As for Seleuceia himself, you should probably place him in his own tier.... With his description being:

"A notorious forum troll, he continually deceives the public with his seemingly well-thought out posts that disguise his true intentions. He does not contribute constructively in and shape or form, but prefers to throw dung from the sidelines, hoping it sticks to the wall. Calls important members of the community trolls and morons, while offering no inputs or thoughts of his own. Has a strange love affair with mountains and tangerines, posting constant gobblygook about them, a shameful display. Seleuceia seems to believe that he is a tier 0 player online, but on closer inspection, it is revealed he has never entered a 5s lobby. His heinous fantasies about being the best ICO player are completely unfounded and is evidence of his numerous paranoid delusions and hallucinations. It is highly recommended that you stay far away from this troll (some might even say troll KING), otherwise he will quickly devour your sanity, leaving nothing but bones behind..."

Updated with everyone's input.

If you guys want to designate me as Fatboy for all the pugs, I don't have a problem with it.  Just leave me for last pick.

I don't think bubbles is anywhere near tier 2, let alone tier 0.

Added schlongdis to tier 4.

Don't make me post that replay Seleuceia... You know, the one where I demonstrate the true power of TEC? 

Seleuceia, I have treated you with respect and dignity throughout my posts. It is sad that you demonstrate no such considerate behavior in return. I urge you to abandon your hostility toward many of the members here, before you are known as an obscene and vulgar person.

Please gtfo woeaintme, your past 10 posts have consisted of nothing insults toward me. They are not only devoid of any substance but clearly had nothing to do with the topic at hand. If you dont have anything to contribute to this list I suggest you leave and go play with easy AI.

Tangerine