I'm not really that into Star Trek anymore. I grew up watching it and I have shelves full of novels based on the various series (I remember thinking that Rules of Engagement by Peter Morwood was what Star Trek VI should have been), but the franchise has always been more about action than new ideas.
I can't help myself but to agree. Just seeing the few shots of the upcoming Star Trek movie makes me cry. Teenagers in space from the looks of it. My guess it'll be some bland action movie just happening to play in the Star Trek universe.
Personally I think Star Trek was at its peak during TNG with Picard preferring a diplomatic solution instead of mindless action or blindly following orders.
A few years ago I found myself in the same position as the OP; I had just read Singularity Sky and Cory Doctorow's Down and Out in the Magic Kingdom, and I suddenly realized I was missing out on lots of really interesting concepts. Then I read every sci-fi book I could get my hands on, and after reading about things like Tines, Whuffie, the Festival, and the Melding Plague, Star Trek was starting to look a little "overdrawn at the mythology bank."
Ack. While Star Trek would probably make a good introduction to the world of Scifi, its universe seems limited, especially on the social aspects. If I were aboard the Enterprise (regardless of any suffix), I'd probably die of boredom. A few lousy holodeck hours, lots of time in 10-forward is all they seem to have to do in their spare time.
Where's the fun? Where are the games? The Internet of the 23rd/24th century? Where are the brain implants? Genetic modifcations? Nano technology? While having the technological level for it, these topics are totally ignored by Star Trek (granted, the genetic engineering is explained in DS9 with Bashir, but still disappointing).
The more I think of it, the more I get the feeling that the whole society in Star Trek is based upon some 60's American middle-classes dream of a perfect life. In other words, dull. One might argue that things like Internet did not exist a few decades ago and so the authors didn't know about it, however there have always been authors that did forsee the technical development.